Message from the Hawks Cast Team || Hawks Cast Forum Rules

The Star Wars Prequels revisited

  • alt text

    So @Zeb-Stark and @Veda-the-Moor always end up talking about Star Wars now and again. We ended up on a path towards the Prequels and the conversation ends up, "well, none of us like them but is there anything redeemable about them?"

    So I know that I couldn't stomach watching all three Prequels so I searched for a couple of fan edits that have condensed them into one movie.

    Currently I'm watching Dawn of the Empire which is a 2.5 hour edit of the like 5-minutes of the Phantom Menace and then 2.45 hours of Attack of the Clones and Revenge of the Sith.

    My take aways:

    • There's so much unnecessary fluff in all three movies that can easily be cut without losing the central theme.
    • Jar Jar is 99.9% cut out of the movie; he gets one scene but never speaks.
    • Phantom Menace is handle via a title-scroll instead of a movie; (no podracing, no midichlorians, no immaculate Jedi conception, no Gungans, no drawn-out Padme hidden among the servants, and no Jedi Council).
    • Actually, almost no Jedi Council at all in the movie.
    • General Genevious is gone.
    • The Republic should have used star ships that more closely resemble TIE Fighters and not the ships that look like the traditional ships you see in the OG Trilogy (A-Wings, B-Wings, X-Wings, & Y-Wings).
    • Their cruisers are essentially OG Star Destroyers but not their star ships... weird.
    • Removed a lot of the slapstick humor; Jar Jar, the Droids silly banter, and no accidental victories.
    • Attack of the Clones focus on Dooku's rise along with the creation of the Clone army.
    • Revenge of the Sith focuses on Anakin's fall.

    What I find interesting right now is that this fan edit was created out of frustration of something that long-time fans loathe... the Prequels. So now I think about all the people that feel that same frustration that has fans much more torn when it comes to the new Trilogy, especially The Last Jedi.

    Anyway, I recommend you search for a condensed movie if you're ever in the mood for the Prequels and don't want to sit through 6+ hours of them.

Log in to reply